Common Sense Media Review
By Nell Minow, based on child development research. How do we rate?
age 7+
Intense animated mustang tale has lots of peril, violence.
-
Parents Need to Know
Parents need to know that Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron is a 2002 movie about a wild mustang stallion that cannot be tamed in the "Wild West." The scenes of Spirit being taken away from his family, and subsequent scenes of Spirit's cruel treatment while men try to "break" him, may be too intense at times for younger or more sensitive viewers. The soldiers use guns and treat Spirit harshly, applying whips and spurs. The blacksmith makes an unsuccessful attempt to brand him. While trying to break Spirit, after all else fails, Spirit is left tied to a post for three days in the hot sun with no food and water. Frequent peril includes a near-drowning scene in which horses are trapped in raging rapids. Characters are in peril and it appears that one has been killed. There's a fire and a chase scene. The Native American boy is portrayed as brave, compassionate, and honorable.
To stay in the loop on more movies like this, you can sign up for weekly Family Movie Night emails.
-
Violence & Scariness
some
Horses in frequent peril. Lead horse taken from his family by U.S. Cavalry. Lead horse shown trying to be trained and broken by a cavalryman. After his attempts fail, cavalryman orders the horse to be tied up, denied food and water for three days. Horses trapped in raging rapids, shown to be almost dead from near-drowning. Lead horse escapes from being part of a team dragging a locomotive up a hill, causes the locomotive to fall and roll down the hill, endangering men and horses, destroying buildings, explosions. Rifle shots. Horse kicks and throws off the men who try to tame him.
Did you know you can flag iffy content? Adjust limits for Violence & Scariness in your kid's entertainment guide.
Get started
-
Drinking, Drugs & Smoking
very little
Cavalryman shown asleep at a campsite next to an almost-empty bottle of booze. Cigar smoking.
Did you know you can flag iffy content? Adjust limits for Drinking, Drugs & Smoking in your kid's entertainment guide.
See AlsoSpirit Untamed Movie ReviewSpirited Movie ReviewCh. 8: The Whiskey RebellionThe House of the Spirits Book ReviewGet started
-
Positive Messages
a little
Positive portrayal of Native Americans.
-
Positive Role Models
very little
No real role models. The antagonists are a regiment of U.S. Cavalry, who are shown fighting and imprisoning Native Americans, kidnapping horses, and voicing opinions that the West is theirs to conquer.
-
Educational Value
none
Meant to entertain rather than educate.
Where to Watch
Videos and Photos
Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron
Parent and Kid Reviews
See all
- Parents say (40)
- Kids say (51)
age 5+
Based on 40 parent reviews
Krispydabell Adult
November 17, 2021
age 5+
I Love This Movie!:
I absolutely loved this movie and I still do! In fact, I grew up on this movie! It’s a household classic with my family! Contrary to the reviews on this movie, as well as the information about this movie, this movie does does have a meaning! The meaning and purpose of this movie is to bring awareness to the treatment of horses in some of the places like the one Spirit was in, as well as how they may obtain the horses in the first place. As for the “violence,” “peril,” and “drinking and smoking,” this was a 2002 movie. Back then, it wasn’t a big deal to show drinks or smoking in cartoons- Gaston and his crew drinks beer in Beauty and the Beast! Same goes for Captain Hook and his crew! As for the violence and peril aspects of the movie, I’m sure I’ve seen equal, if not more, violence and peril in Disney movies alone growing up, not even counting Dreamworks and Blue Sky films! So is this movie okay for your child to watch? In my opinion, yes- absolutely! Have fun laughing, comfort each other when crying (it’s a tearjerker sometimes!), and, most importantly, reiterate the overall message and awareness this movie brings. It’s a lovely movie! I highly recommend this movie for all families to watch and enjoy!
Uzelacjosh Adult
May 19, 2021
age 2+
The person who gave this an official review is drunk
To say this rating is inaccurate is an understatement. First of all, the movie is undoubtedly a 5/5 rating despite what anybody says. It caters to all ages, ethnicities, genders, political/religious affiliations, and pretty much anyone else who has a pulse. It’s one of the greatest animated films of all time, and here’s why:Spirit, the brave and unwavering heroic stallion, teaches every audience the importance of unconditional loyalty through his journey of being captured, getting enslaved, and fighting for his and his family’s freedom. Please name another animated movie that has a deeper, more intense plot than this. I’ll wait.So often we take for granted our upbringing. We forget about the people who have invested in us from the very beginning- our mothers (in this specific movie, an independent, SINGLE mother), our supportive family members and friends (Spirit’s close herd), and the mentors who always directed us back to what matters most in life (the soaring eagle which guided Spirit throughout his journey). Spirit reminds us of what it means to “give back” to the community that raised us. For the reviewer to say there are no role models in this movie is pure ignorance. This horse’s determination was powerful enough to effect multiple human beings, including Little Creek. This young Native American experienced a constant theme of Spirit’s heroism. From escaping the the fort via horseback, to dodging the blow from a bullet, to flying over the canyon ridge (again, via horseback), the man had no option but to honor and respect the stallion towards the end of the journey. He did so to the level of giving up his own beloved horse to be free with Spirit. Now to the person who represented Common Sense Reviews, how does this NOT represent a role model figure? Secondly, the horse had uncanny grit to experience what he experienced. Imagine getting kidnapped, harassed, shipped away hundreds of miles from home, and then enslaved. For any average person (much less, a horse), that’s quite a physical and emotional beat down. Not one minute did Spirit stray away from his ultimate mission of getting home to his family. He endured unimaginable exhaustion and pain in being taken by multiple human groups, he loved and lost love and had to find love all over again, he labored for days on end traveling hundreds of miles to get home. Nothing stopped him from achieving his goals, which is something I would say any true, noble role model exhibits. The person who represented Common Sense Reviews must not understand what it takes to WIN in life. Everything else in this 3/5 star review is stupid, too. Nobody cares about the bottles and smoke laying by the campfire. I didn’t even notice those things until they were pointed out. That’s just petty.... The horses were “in frequent peril”.... well YEAH OF COURSE THEY WERE. I don’t know how that’s any different from Belle being afraid of the Beast, or Marlin being afraid of a barracuda. Don’t knock the score for “violence” because of a natural state of being while in an uncomfortable situation. Lastly, to say that there’s no educational value to this movie is just absurd. I don’t even have to expand on this because everyone who has a functioning brain knows that there are historical and life lessons to take away from this story. To the person who represented Common Sense Reviews, please give credit where credit is due, and please go obtain some common sense for yourself.
See all 40 parent reviews
What's the Story?
In the animated SPIRIT: STALLION OF THE CIMARRON, Spirit is born to a loving mare and grows up in a paradise of mountains and plains, with plenty to eat and drink and freedom to run as far as he can dream. He becomes the leader of the pack of horses, and watches out for his group to keep them safe from predators. His curiosity leads him to investigate a campsite, and he's captured by cavalry soldiers. A brutal commander tries to break him, but even starvation doesn't make him submit. Spirit escapes with an Indian boy named Little Creek, and they grow to care for each other. Spirit also cares for Little Creek's pretty palomino, Rain. But Spirit still will not let anyone ride him. Little Creek sends Spirit back to his home, but he's captured again and has many more adventures before returning to his family.
Is It Any Good?
Our review:
Parents say (40):
Kids say (51):
Many kids will enjoy this traditionally animated story about a brave wild mustang in the 19th-century American West, but parents may find it overlong even at a running time of less than 90 minutes. Parents should also know that there are some scary scenes and that the story may be hard for younger children to follow because the horse characters don't talk.
There are some lovely and powerful images of horses racing through endless stretches of grass, mountains, and rivers. The scary scenes are very vivid, especially the fire and a railroad engine knocked off its tracks that comes tumbling downhill. But the story moves slowly, especially during the dreary Bryan Adams songs. The narration (by Matt Damon) is more poetic than descriptive, so younger kids will benefit from some discussion about the story.
Talk to Your Kids About ...
Families can talk about the different ways that the Colonel and Little Creek have of trying to teach Spirit to carry a rider. Do different parents have different ways of teaching children? What ways work best?
How are Native Americans and the U.S. Cavalry portrayed in this movie? How is this in contrast to the way Native Americans and the U.S. Cavalry have historically been portrayed in Western movies?
Was the violence necessary for telling the story, or was it too much? Why?
Movie Details
- In theaters : May 24, 2002
- On DVD or streaming : November 19, 2002
- Cast : Chopper Bernet, James Cromwell, Matt Damon
- Directors : Kelly Asbury, Lorna Cook
- Studio : DreamWorks
- Genre : Family and Kids
- Topics : Adventures, Horses and Farm Animals
- Run time : 83 minutes
- MPAA rating : G
- MPAA explanation : scenes of peril, scary fire
- Last updated : September 6, 2024
Did we miss something on diversity?
Research shows a connection between kids' healthy self-esteem and positive portrayals in media. That's why we've added a new "Diverse Representations" section to our reviews that will be rolling out on an ongoing basis. You can help us help kids by
Spirit: Stallion of the Cimarron
Suggest an Update
Your privacy is important to us. We won't share this comment without your permission. If you chose to provide an email address, it will only be used to contact you about your comment. See our privacy policy.